PDF Ebook Arguing about Slavery: The Great Battle in the United States Congress, by William Lee Miller
Why should soft file? As this Arguing About Slavery: The Great Battle In The United States Congress, By William Lee Miller, many individuals additionally will certainly should get the book earlier. But, sometimes it's up until now way to get guide Arguing About Slavery: The Great Battle In The United States Congress, By William Lee Miller, also in various other country or city. So, to alleviate you in discovering guides Arguing About Slavery: The Great Battle In The United States Congress, By William Lee Miller that will certainly support you, we help you by providing the listings. It's not just the list. We will certainly offer the suggested book Arguing About Slavery: The Great Battle In The United States Congress, By William Lee Miller web link that can be downloaded and install straight. So, it will not need more times and even days to position it and other books.
Arguing about Slavery: The Great Battle in the United States Congress, by William Lee Miller
PDF Ebook Arguing about Slavery: The Great Battle in the United States Congress, by William Lee Miller
Is Arguing About Slavery: The Great Battle In The United States Congress, By William Lee Miller book your preferred reading? Is fictions? Just how's regarding history? Or is the best seller unique your selection to satisfy your downtime? Or perhaps the politic or spiritual publications are you searching for currently? Here we go we offer Arguing About Slavery: The Great Battle In The United States Congress, By William Lee Miller book collections that you require. Bunches of numbers of publications from several fields are supplied. From fictions to scientific research as well as religious can be looked and also figured out here. You might not stress not to discover your referred publication to review. This Arguing About Slavery: The Great Battle In The United States Congress, By William Lee Miller is among them.
It can be among your early morning readings Arguing About Slavery: The Great Battle In The United States Congress, By William Lee Miller This is a soft file book that can be managed downloading and install from online book. As known, in this advanced era, modern technology will alleviate you in doing some tasks. Also it is just reviewing the visibility of book soft data of Arguing About Slavery: The Great Battle In The United States Congress, By William Lee Miller can be extra feature to open. It is not only to open up and also save in the gizmo. This time around in the early morning and other downtime are to check out guide Arguing About Slavery: The Great Battle In The United States Congress, By William Lee Miller
The book Arguing About Slavery: The Great Battle In The United States Congress, By William Lee Miller will still make you good worth if you do it well. Finishing the book Arguing About Slavery: The Great Battle In The United States Congress, By William Lee Miller to check out will certainly not become the only goal. The objective is by getting the good worth from the book till completion of guide. This is why; you have to learn more while reading this Arguing About Slavery: The Great Battle In The United States Congress, By William Lee Miller This is not only how quick you read a publication and also not just has how many you finished the books; it has to do with what you have obtained from guides.
Considering the book Arguing About Slavery: The Great Battle In The United States Congress, By William Lee Miller to review is likewise needed. You can select guide based upon the favourite styles that you such as. It will involve you to enjoy reviewing other publications Arguing About Slavery: The Great Battle In The United States Congress, By William Lee Miller It can be likewise concerning the necessity that binds you to check out the book. As this Arguing About Slavery: The Great Battle In The United States Congress, By William Lee Miller, you can discover it as your reading book, also your preferred reading publication. So, discover your preferred publication below and also get the link to download and install the book soft file.
A blow-by-blow re-creation of the battle royal that raged in Congress in the 1830s, when a small band of representatives, led by President John Quincy Adams of Massachusetts, employed intricate stratagems to outwit the Southern (and Southern-sympathizing) sponsors of the successive "gag" rules that had long blocked debate on the subject of slavery.
- Sales Rank: #650719 in Books
- Published on: 1996-01-16
- Released on: 1996-01-16
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.75" h x 6.50" w x 1.50" l,
- Binding: Hardcover
- 577 pages
From Publishers Weekly
In tracing the growing hostility between North and South over the extension of slavery into the Western territories, Miller (The First Liberty) pays special attention to the so-called gag rule, in force from 1834 to 1844, which blocked discussion of antislavery proposals in the House of Representatives. The central figure in Miller's study is John Quincy Adams, in his second career as U.S. representative from Massachusetts, and his heroic fight for repeal of the gag rule and for the right to petition Congress for the abolition of slavery. The author recounts how the ex-president succeeded in spite of the bitter denunciation of his opponents and a concerted effort in 1842 to have him censured. Miller calls the repeal of the gag rule "the first clear victory over the Slave Power in the United States." He captures the confrontations on the floor of the House and the eloquence of the speakers, in a conflict of words and ideas that would ultimately lead to the Civil War. BOMC selection.
Copyright 1995 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Miller (The First Liberty, LJ 2/1/86) covers the great debates in the House of Representatives from 1835 to 1845 on the legality of slavery in the United States. Even though the period is well before the Civil War, the author feels that this battle really began the intense feelings that culminated in the war. He sets the stage for the debate, then intersperses direct quotations from the Congressional Globe and Register of Debates, with the personal beliefs of the participants, the mood and feelings from the various regions or states, as well as his own interpretation of the discussions. Miller ties all this together within a framework of the political climate and writings of the period. He gives an excellent portrayal of the House of Representatives, its makeup, and especially its leadership. His book should be required reading for anyone interested in the slavery issue, as well as the history of the U.S. Congress, since it examines both with exceptional clarity.
W. Walter Wicker, Louisiana Technical Univ., Ruston
Copyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Booklist
According to Miller, he was working on a project "on America's moral and intellectual underpinnings" when he came upon the subject of this book, and it grabbed him by his collar, threw him to the floor, sat on his chest, and insisted that it be told. A bit melodramatic, perhaps, but his subject is an extraordinary episode in U.S. history. It was a long argument that took place mostly on the floor of the House of Representatives, in the 1830s and early 1840s, over the right of the people, particularly nonvoting women, to petition, when those petitions begged for the ending of the slave trade in the capital, when those petitions came from slaves ("they are property, not persons; they have no political rights" ), and, in the end, when those petitions even mentioned slavery. So then, this little-known controversy was an argument to end American slavery without destroying the Union, before there was an inkling of the Civil War. The hero is John Quincy Adams, an ex-president, who presented more of those petitions than any other representative, particularly after Representative Waddy Thompson attempted to censure him for it. Thompson didn't realize "he mistook his man." After a nine-year struggle, during which gag rules were passed and two attempts were made to censure him, Adams defeated the gag rule on petition. Miller's book is of the utmost importance, for it shows how close we were to moral destruction in those days of state's rights and suggests how close we are again. Bonnie Smothers
Most helpful customer reviews
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful.
Miller should be lionized
By Rick Davis
Miller, as all know,is a national treasure. No one I know could have made this subject breathe nearly two centuries later. I wonder if anyone else could have guessed the importance of the subject.
Miller gets in the mind(s) of his (historical) characters better than anyone else. He is always a good read; deep, colorful, poignant. He is a national treasure.
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful.
a revelation
By I. Gimlet
Arguing About Slavery has a very difficult subject to make live, what William Lee Miller calls the "tedium and sublimity" of republican debate. The historian's duty to be evenhanded even when faced with the moral pit of slavery doesn't make the job any easier. Yet, Miller handles these problems with aplomb and, more, handily succeeds.
At about 500 pages, Arguing About Slavery is concerned with the parliamentary debate and tactics used by pro-slavery and anti-slavery forces in the Congress in the 1830's and 40's. It shows how, nearly single handedly, John Quincy Adams insistence on the right to petition exposed the South's determination to controvert the Constitution in its quest to shelter the practice of slavery from congressional criticism. By the time the Congress puts the "gag rule" to rest, Adam's exposé had made abolitionism a powerful and accepted political force in the North.
Miller storytelling skills has the reader discovering the extent of sophistry the pro-slavery forces were willing to go to as they were forced to resort to deeper and deeper hypocrisy. He does this, however, without denigrating the men of the South. Indeed, much of the enjoyment you'll derive from reading Arguing About Slavery will come from the rhetorical skills the Southern Congressmen liberally display throughout.
Although Miller's protagonist is clearly J.Q. Adams, he spends considerable effort on a broad cast of characters, from the original abolitionists and their puritan backgrounds -- the Grimké sisters, Theodore Weld, Elizur Wright, Elijah Lovejoy -- to Adam's allies in the House -- Joshua Giddings, William Slade -- to the pro-slavery giants -- John C. Calhoun, Caleb Cushing, Francis Pinkens -- and moderates like Henry Pinkney (whose gag rule ironically was intended as a compromise) and President Martin Van Buren. If these biographies are not familiar to you, these and others in Arguing About Slavery should be. Miller describes the history and premises of all parties involved, but doesn't interrupt the flow of the tale to do so.
Miller does an incredible job of making the tedium and sublimity of republican debate come alive and at the end of the book you better understand the place of liberty in America's national consciousness, the intellectual forces that led to the Civil War, and the nature of the founders' relationship to the practice of slavery itself. The only criticism I have is that sometimes Miller's rhetoric is a bit too partisan, which reduces the value of the book as ammunition against slavery's apologists, which do still exist. But that has nothing to do with merits of the book as a work of the historical art, which are excellent.
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful.
An enaging work on an important period of American history.
By thutchin@providence.edu
William Lee Miller, the wonderfully readable historian and author of a number of political history books, here turns his attentian to the United States Congress. His protaganist is John Quincy Adams, (of recent AMISTED fame) fighting the Southern block of congressmen who want to keep petitions for the abolition of slavery off the floor of the House of Representatives. The question of wether Adams will eventually defeat the "Gag Rule" builds from begining to end.
Miller's real strength, however, is his ability to write. He turns what could have been a dry history of congressional politics into a battle for the very soul of the nation. When Adams finnaly wins the battle, in the end, while nearly dying on the floor of congress, you want to stand up and cheer.
This episode of American history has rarely been given more than a line or two from the average college textbook. But by reading this book, you become half convinced this was one of the most momentous occasions in the history of the American nation, and perhaps that is the finist compliment I can give William Lee Miller.
Arguing about Slavery: The Great Battle in the United States Congress, by William Lee Miller PDF
Arguing about Slavery: The Great Battle in the United States Congress, by William Lee Miller EPub
Arguing about Slavery: The Great Battle in the United States Congress, by William Lee Miller Doc
Arguing about Slavery: The Great Battle in the United States Congress, by William Lee Miller iBooks
Arguing about Slavery: The Great Battle in the United States Congress, by William Lee Miller rtf
Arguing about Slavery: The Great Battle in the United States Congress, by William Lee Miller Mobipocket
Arguing about Slavery: The Great Battle in the United States Congress, by William Lee Miller Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar